Showing posts with label Rigging. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rigging. Show all posts

Saturday, October 26, 2024

The Goofy X-Spread Rig on The F-24 MKI

10-26-2024, rev. 11-6-202, rev. 11-27-202, rev. 12-7-2024

The failure of an F-24 mast at the lower diamond wire junction this week (not my boat) started me thinking about the odd rig on this boat. It was not used on any other F-boat, and in fact, no other boat that I can find. Supposedly Gino Morreli designed the rig, but he's a smart guy and he never used this design on any other boat. I'm think it's far more likely this was a John Walton (son of Walmart founder Sam Walton) design choice, one of many that Ian did not approve of. Oops.

 

 The failure point was just above the lower (forward) diamond wires. Note also that it was sideways (as typical), not in the direction of the forward wires, suggesting to me that they are not helpful.

Mono-hulls are typically rigged with spreaders and shrouds anchored to the deck. This provides side support with no added compression load. The proportional stretch of the uppers and lowers insures that the mast remains accurately in column, even as it is slightly deflected to the side under wind loads. Masts, when they buckle are failing in compression. Occasionally a jumper diamond is provided on the front to control the bend of a very slender mast, though larger mast sections and those stabilized with pre-bend typically do not require this extra support.

 


One the left (F-24) rig there are two sets of diamond wires on each side. The drawing omits the outer set on the left and the inner set on the right for clarity. Those are not loaded when the mast is pressed to the side and forward reaching.

 Re. Center of effort.  According to calculations based on ABS (American Bureau of Shipping) documents, the force on a sail is primarily concentrated on the head, clew, and tack. A quick look at the reinforcements and the arraignment of fibers in load path sails makes this obvious. Consider how the luff is relaxed when the sail is backwinded. In fact, about 65% of the sail force above the boom is concentrated at the head, with the balance spread along the luff tape. The load is NOT uniformly distributed along the mast, as commonsense might first suggest.

 

The weird F-24 X-spreaders. The forward spreaders hold the shorter wires. The aft spreaders are about the typical rake angle and provide the pre-bend. 


 F-24 manual image.

 

Multihull masts are often rigged with big rotating masts for several reasons. A big main is advantageous, as it provides accurate heel control through twist and easing the mainsheet. They can tolerate a heavier mast (rotating masts must be heavier because the staying is less efficient) because they heel less and as a result, the mast is not outboard, contributing to heel. They have a wide shroud base, reducing the need for spreaders to create angle. Often multihulls cannot sustain high mast base compression loads because there either is no center hull, or in the case of trimarans, because it is lightly built, without the need for structure to support a keel.  For the same reasons, rotating masts are nearly non-existent on monohulls. Because there can be no fixed spreaders to carry side loads, rotating masts use diamond wires, and it works out well that they rotate with the mast, supporting the weak side of a thin, aerodynamic wind section. Forward support isn't needed, because the mast is wide in that direction. The diamond spreaders are angles aft to help create some pre-bend, which helps with mast stability (resists inversion and pumping) and with draft control (you can de-power by de-rotating the mast which pulls cloth out of the sail, reducing draft).

 The combination of diamond wires, aft-swept spreaders, and aft-angled cap shrouds also helps eliminate the need for a fixed backstay, something that is problematic with a high roach mainsail, the other half of the quick-heel-control formula. It's hard to maintain enough forestay tension without a backstay, and savy multihull sailors quickly learn to compensate with a tight mainsheet.

But the F-24 MKI mast does not rotate, so why the diamond wires, instead of fixed shrouds? It's easier to step the mast when trailering, since no tensioning is required. The center hull is relatively narrow and very light, with no good place to anchor the shrouds. There is also the need for aft-raked cap shrouds to replace the backstay. Of course, many cruising cats have either conventional shrouds or diamond wire stays with aft raked cap shrouds and no second set of diamonds.



There are several problems with the willy-nilly addition of stays without working through the design. When a mast fails, it fails in compression. Like buckling a drinking straw, the tensioned side does not tear, it is always the compressed inner side that buckles inwards. Every additional wire and its associated pretension adds compression, so unless it provides needed support, it actually weakens the mast. The more wires, the more compression. Calculations of buckling strength for this mast sections give a compression working load of 6,500 pounds. Rough calculations based on wind pressure and heeling force (the boat was reefed and very close reaching) and bending moment at the failure point  show that the mast failed under a compression load of about 12,000 pounds (if distributed--this reflects the probable stress on the side that failed). This is well over the safe working load of the section, but less than the expected failure strength.

If we total up the compression loads from the shrouds, diamond wires and other rigging ...

  • Forestay. 2200 pounds
  • Shrouds (only one is under much tension sailing under full load). 1200 pounds
  • Mainsheet. 300 pounds
  • Halyard, jib. 300 pounds. Note, jib halyard tension does not change forestay tension + halyard tensions at the mast, only between the mast and the anchor point at the furler. The total is fixed by shroud and mainsheet tension contributions.
  • Halyard, main. 500 pounds
  • Cunningham. Does not count, since it just offsets friction in the mast groove, from head to foot.
  • Forward diamonds. 1000 pounds total (but not included at failure point)
  • Aft diamonds. 2400 pounds total

... and adjusting for angles (only part of the tension is directed in-column) we get about 6,500 pounds total. That does not allow a lot for bending moment. Curiously, 36% of this is from the diamond wires and 10% from the forward diamonds, which we don't need; there is very little forward load on the mast, and the center of the force is near the head of the sail (forces perpendicular to the luff tape are very low, except near the head and tack--not the wrinkles, the luffing when backwinded, and the lack of significant reinforcement on the slug grommets).

The rigging guide gives 500 pounds max for the forward diamonds and 1000 pounds max for the aft diamonds. But what if they really don't need pretension for stretch, since the mast is not bending? Then the pretension for the aft shrouds needs to be just enough to establish the prebend (0.8% of length), and forward diamonds just enough to keep them from going slack, since we probably do not need them at all. But I'm disinclined to remove them entirely, and going slack might allow them to jump out of their fittings. 

10-29-2024. I checked the tensions on my F-24 MKI.

Wire                  Observed (pounds)              Maxium Spec (pounds)            Re-set to (pounds)

Shrouds             800  (may reach spec in strong winds)  1500                       (adjusted each sail)

Forestay            (same as shrouds by geometry, except as increased by mainsheet tension)

Aft Diamond     1400 (over spec, below)      1000                                           800

Fore Diamond    800  (over spec below)       500                                             350  ____________

Total Diamonds  4400                                    3000                                           2300

 This represents a (4400-2300)/6500=32% reduction in mast compression, which translates dirrectly into a 32% increase in strength. 

Data source: from the 1992 F-24 manual

 

 Worse, exactly where the reefed main applies it's greatest force (65% of the drive above the boom), just above the forward diamond wire anchors, the lee diamond wire is pulling down and to leeward. And that is where the mast buckled to leeward with a reefed main. The smoking gun. Removing or slacking the forward diamonds also reduces this stress. 

What if the mast raising stays were snugged and perhaps reinforced in the deck (Lower shroud)? This is a conventional rigging solutions? This stabilizes the lower mast with less compression in the critical area. It would also help to move the anchor point slightly aft and outboard, while staying inside the jib track.

Takeaways? The forward diamond wires increase compression and pull in the wrong direction without providing any useful improvement in mast stability. Best would be a re-designed mast with only one set of aft-swept spreaders. The less drastic solution is to reduce the tension on the forward diamonds; I judged 300 pounds to be sufficient preload and sailing observations confirmed they do not go fully slack.The aft diamond wires should be just tight enough to create 2.5 inches of pre-bend (as specified by Ian Farier)  and no more. These serve a purpose, but extra tension does not help. 800 pounds appears to be sufficient, and I may reduce this, based on further sailing observations in strong conditions. 

Will I reinforce the deck and improve the lower shroud? Undecided. No. The wires are too small to bother.

Time will tell, but I'm comfortable with my calculations. The mast should now be 30-35% stronger, no small improvement.

---

rev. 12-7-2024

 

A few more ideas. I could support the center by running a second set of shrouds to the same anchor point. In this way, they would move together.  In addition, they would be tensioned along with the cap shrouds. My gut is that fixing the diamond wires makes this unnecessary. I have to address the diamonds anyway.


 

Monday, July 22, 2024

Marking Chain

Knowing how much rode you have out is essential to proper anchoring. Before I had a windlass, using an all-fiber rode, I would measure it out as deployed, counting the fathoms by arm span. I can time the windlass (about 6 feet per second) but I always lose count. I tried the traditional bits of twine and the more modern approach of cable ties, but my windlass hates anything attached to the chain. Twine would jam on the stripper and cables ties were sheared off cleanly after a few cycles, the broken bits causing jams. The most obvious Solution was paint.

But how to mark 100 feet of chain on-deck without making a mess?
  • Flake out the chain in even loops. In this case, 10-foot lengths fit across the tramp.
  • Pick marking points and temporarily mark with tape. I chose 25, 50, 75, and 100 feet.
  • Collect a box from the dumpster, notch it as needed, and paint away. Plain-old Rustoleum or anything similar will hold-up for years; it chips going through the windlass but remains visible between the links.
  • Just leave the box on-deck until your next visit, to make sure it's dry. No rush.
Easy, fast, and neat. I painted the chain on the deck in a light breeze with no real risk of over-spray mess.

My 100-foot mark is long because I like to keep the splice off the windlass. Ever since I changed to the Irony Splice it passes just fine, but it's easy to attach the bridle if I stay on the chain.



Wednesday, April 3, 2024

Chafe. Which Nylon Rope Weave Last Longest


I’ve suggested climbing ropes for a number of uses around the boat, including tethers, traveler control lines and snubbers. Some folks misunderstood, believing I was suggesting that climbing rope is globally better, and some misinterpret climbing test results, conjuring up negatives that don’t actually exist (climbing ropes are sacrificial, some how crumpling to absorb impact). Time to set a few myths straight.
 
Climbing rope is among the highest quality products out there. Logically, there is no market for anything less, since your life, very literally, hangs by a thread. But that does not mean it is better in all ways. In fact, the base material is no different than good quality marine rope, it's just woven differently.
 
The Cover. Or mantle, as it is called by climbers, is woven more tightly than double braid because this makes it less snag prone on rock. This also makes it more abrasion resistant against rock, coral and rough materials, because strands do not snag and cut. However, this does not make it wear longer through a chock. Double braid carries 50% of its material and strength in the core and 50% in the cover. This provides balance in spliced eyes. Climbing rope, on the other hand, typically places only 28-35% of the material in the cover, saving space for more core, which is what absorbs impact. Additionally, the tight cover makes dynamic climbing rope practically impossible to splice. You can’t open it enough to milk the core out, and if you do, you have no chance of burying it back in the main line far enough to make a strong splice. The core and cover are not balanced. Climbers don’t care, because a splice would only snag in a crack when they pulled the rope up. They use knots. And coincidentally, the core design is less sensitive to strength loss in knots, because the floating yarns do not feel the short radius. They are also less prone to fatigue, because there is less yarn-against-yarn friction. Climbing ropes are sometimes supplied with sewn eyes in the end; this should be only be done by companies familiar with sewing climbing rope and fall protection assemblies.
 
Core. Instead of braid or lay, the core consists of free floating yarns. Half are twisted in the conventional direction (s-twist) and half in the opposite direction (z-twist).  Unlike laid rope, this make the line non-rotational under load; you hang on a 3-strand rope, the lay will straighten a little and you will spin. Darn inconvenient for the climber and prone to hockling or twisting in tackles. This free floating construction also maximizes stretch and reduces the tendency to cut if stressed hard in a fall over an edge. This latter characteristic is vital to climbers, since in the real world, climbing ropes only fail over sharp edges.
 
UV. Climbing ropes are somewhat more vulnerable because the mantle (cover) is thinner. However, climbers retire ropes after relativly few (compared to sailors) hours in the sun, so this is not a big issue. It often looks worse than it is, because climbing ropes are dyed bright colors for visibility and fading is obvious.
 
Fatigue. There is an annoying myth that somehow climbing ropes have poor fatigue resistance because they fail within 5-12 drop tests. The folk leaping to this incorrect conclusion assume they are somehow sacrificial, because that feels like common sense to them, but this is without any basis in fact. The truth is exactly the opposite. First, only climbing ropes can pass the drop test. All other weaves and rope types fail in less than the minimum number of cycles, or if strong enough, result in an impact force that would either tear anchors loose from the cliff or injure the climber. Second, the drop test, which is sudden, severe, and intentionally takes place across a sharp edge, has no relevance to actual use within the allowable working load. In fact, the free floating yarns naturally experience less yarn-to-yarn chafe and withstand fatigue much better than other weaves. Obvious, really. The fatigue life of climbing ropes is several times better than other nylon weaves and comparable to polyester double braid, but with more stretch (wind farm research into mooring lines).

 
So how do they stack up? Among nylon rope constructions, which should you chose?
 
[The images are of tests performed by swinging a heavily weighted rope pendulum so that it dragged across a cinder block, simulating rocks, coral, and concrete docks.] 
 
Double Braid
  • Good flexibility.
  • Fair knotting.
  • Medium grip.
  • Moderate splicing difficulty.
  • Medium to poor chafe resistance .
  • Less stretch .
  • Poor fatigue resistance.

Economy, good hand, medium chafe resistance, economy, and reasonable splicability makes it is popular for docklines and smaller anchor lines. 3-strand is a better choice for docklines if chafe is a serious problem. 3-strand or brait is preferred for larger dock lines. The same loose braid that makes splicing easy makes it prone to snagging on rough surfaces, increasing chafe in some cases. Not a great choice for anchor rope, since combination windlasses can’t grab it, it is hard to store, chafe resistance is limited, and so is stretch. OK for traveler control lines.


Plaited rope
  • Better flexibility.
  • Good knotting.
  • Better grip.
  • Easy to splice.
  • Poor chafe resistant.
  • More stretch.
  • Better fatigue resistance.

The primary advantages are ease of splicing, compact storage (it is very limp), and increased stretch. However, the loose weave reduces chafe resistance because it can snag very easily on rocks. The only thing I like it for is big docklines. Some favor it for anchor lines, but they haven’t looked at the chafe test results.


3-Strand
  • Less flexibility.
  • Better grip.
  • Poor knotting.
  • Easy to splice.
  • Good chafe resistance.
  • More stretch.
  • Better fatigue resistance.
Good grip, chafe resistance, ease of splicing, and stretch make it the top choice for anchor lines and docklines in tough locations. Also excellent for anchor snubbers, particularly if chafe is an issue. If you need more stretch, make the snubber a little longer, up to about 40 feet.
 
Dynamic Climbing Rope
  • Good flexibility.
  • Best knotting.
  • Less grip.
  • Very difficult to splice. Use knots or professional sewing.
  • Moderate to good chafe resistant. About equal to polyester double braid but not quite as good as 3-strand..
  • Most stretch.
  • Best fatigue resistance.
In spite of having a lighter cover, climbing rope is very chafe resistant, This is because, like webbing, the tight cover resists snagging. Instead, it fuzzes, resisting wear.

Limited grip and chafe resistance limit the usefulness of climbing rope as anchor rode to boats less than 27 feet long, where it excels. However, it is a top choice for traveler control lines because it wears well, runs well through blocks, will not tangle, is comfortable in the hand and has superior stretch (eyes are sewn--DIY is acceptable because the load is low). If you need extra long tethers (a multihull thing) it is just the thing, but you will either have to knot the ends or have them professionally sewn (not a sail maker, but an arborist gear company—it’s a specialty). Use 8mm for this; larger climbing ropes roll underfoot too much. .Finally, dynamic climbing rope is only available as twin (6-7mm), half (7-8mm) and single (9-11mm).
 
Conclusions. Unsurprisingly, the best product depends on the application. I like 3-strand for anchor rope and snubbers, double braid for docklines, plaited rope for big dock lines, and climbing rope for long tethers, travelers, and snubbers. Horses for courses.