Velcro For Winch Handles

 rev. 7-24-2024

 I tested this for a month. It was OK but just didn't suit my style.

I ended up making a custom holder from PVC pipe that ...

• Is cut on an angle so the handle always lays against the bulkhead
• Fits snugly in an unused corner.
• Has no bottom so it never gets dirt in it.
• Attached with VHB tape. VERY strong, no new holes. Do wipe the surfaces with alcohol first.

 But Velcro did work. The handle never fell off.

 I've never been a fan of the PVC pockets. Cloth ones only last so long. PVC pipe can be pretty good, but it works best in a corner (see above).

What about Velcro? I've been seeing this on more and more sport boats, and I can see some advantages:

• A fraction faster.
• No holes to drill.
• Might lose more handles ... or fewer if the pockets aren't being used.
• Can store grip-down, making it less snag prone.
• Velcro will only be good for about 2 years in the sun.
• The hooks can grab some fabrics, but located low this is unlikely.
• Fits all sizes.
• Could be horizontal.
  
• Grip won't mar the gel coat. 
• Not in the way when not in use. Put a pad by every winch ... but then where is the handle?
  

On the other hand

• Grabbing the handle might be more awkward. 
• It will get dirty and green.
  
• Can't be used for anything else.

You could do both. 1-2 conventional pockets, and then pads near every winch.  I may try that.

The hook part goes on the boat and the loops on the handle. I guess it could go either way, but hooks on the handle would feel strange and not give a good grip.